Showing posts with label government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label government. Show all posts

Net firms reject monitoring role

Saturday, February 16, 2008

Space shuttle takes off, AP
All net firms keep an eye on how much people download
UK net firms are resisting government suggestions that they should do more to monitor what customers do online.

The industry association for net providers said legal and technical barriers prohibit them from being anything other than a "mere conduit".

The declaration comes as the government floats the idea of persistent pirates being denied net access.

And in the US one net supplier has admitted to "degrading" traffic from some file-sharing networks.

Traffic control

Net firms have been stung into defining their position by the emergence this week of a draft government consultation document that suggests ISPs should be drafted in to the fight against piracy.

It suggested that people who persistently download and share copyrighted material could have their net access removed.

A spokesman for the Internet Service Providers Association (ISPA) said the 2002 E-Commerce Regulations defined net firms as "mere conduits" and not responsible for the contents of the traffic flowing across their networks.

If they didn't do traffic management we would all complain

The spokesman said technical issues also made it hard for net firms to take action against specific types of traffic.

For instance, he said, while some people use peer-to-peer networks to download copyrighted material many commercial services, such as Napster and the BBC's iPlayer, use file-sharing technology to distribute music and TV legally.

In the US, Comcast admitted in documents filed with the Federal Communications Commission that it does "degrade" some traffic from peer-to-peer networks.

The spokesman added: "We know that all ISPs are involved in traffic management but that is to optimise the service for all their customers."

A spokesman for Virgin Media said its traffic management system came into play during peak times - between 1600 and 2100.

Action was taken against any customer whose usage exceeded a limit associated with their tariff during that five hour window, he said.

"If you exceed that threshold we will drop your speed for five hours from when the excess is recorded," he said.

Hand on computer mouse, Eyewire
Browsing speeds are most often managed during the busiest times

Andrew Ferguson, an editor at Think Broadband, said net service firms manage their bandwidth in many different ways.

Almost all, he said, manage traffic but at certain times impose other systems to smooth out the peaks.

"Some firms will happily let you use as much as you like but will charge you accordingly, and business products that are more expensive often allow unlimited use," he said.

Others impose charges on customers who regularly exceed their download limits and a few manage their system so users cannot exceed a monthly download cap. The limits that firms impose can also vary widely.

"Any ISP that does not do traffic management is not going to stay in business very long," said Gavin Johns, managing director of net management firm Epitiro.

He said it was essential to ensure that services which have to be delivered in real time, such as voice and streaming video, were usable.

"Different applications use different ports and have different payloads," said Mr Johns, "They look completely different from a network point of view."

"If they didn't do traffic management we would all complain," he said.

Mr Ferguson from Think Broadband said although traffic management was common, net providers imposed it in contrasting ways.

"What varies is the degree it impacts users and the openness of providers in telling users it exists and what is and is not managed," he told the BBC News website.

"Traffic management has a poor reputation as in many cases it is used to keep bandwidth costs down for a provider with little respect to the consumers' wishes," he said.Building a nation Voters, boycotters Media spotlight

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Anti file-sharing laws considered

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Lord Triesman
The government cannot tolerate stealing, said Lord Triesman
The UK government could legislate to crack down on illegal file-sharers, a senior politician has told the BBC's iPM programme.

Lord Triesman, the parliamentary Under Secretary for Innovation, Universities and Skills, said intellectual property theft would not be tolerated.

"If we can't get voluntary arrangements we will legislate," he said.

The comments could prove controversial with privacy advocates and internet service providers.

Lord Triesman called on internet service providers to take a "more activist role" in the problem of illegal file-sharing.

Data banks

There are ongoing talks between internet service providers and the music industry and these are, said Lord Triesman, "progressing more promisingly than people might have thought six months ago".

"For the most part I think there are going to be successful voluntary schemes between the creative industries and ISPs. Our preferred position is that we shouldn't have to regulate," he said.

He admitted that the technology necessary to track illegal file sharing would mean that "it is quite possible to know where it is happening and who it is happening with".

While he said that the government had no interest in "hounding 14-year-olds who shared music", it was intent on tracking down those who made multiple copies for profit.

"Where people have registered music as an intellectual property I believe we will be able to match data banks of that music to music going out and being exchanged on the net," he said.

"We have some simple choices to make. If creative artists can't earn a living as a result of the work they produce, then we will kill off creative artists and that would be a tragedy."

Mere conduit

Man being arrested
This week a man was arrested in connection with pirate music site

The debate centre around peer-to-peer (P2P) technology, applications that allow internet users to exchange files with each other directly or through a mediating server.

Computer users with the same type of P2P application can connect to each other and directly access files from one another's hard drives.

Some people are using peer-to-peer applications to copy or distribute files including copyrighted material such as music, films and software without paying royalties.

People who do this may be infringing the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

There have been various crack-downs on such applications. Most recently the UK-run members-only site OiNK was shut down and several properties in the UK and Holland were raided.

'Misbegotten idea'

The Internet Service Providers Association has always maintained that it cannot be held responsible for illegal peer-to-peer traffic because it is "merely a conduit" of such material.

"ISPA does not support abuses of copyright and intellectual property theft," said an ISPA spokesman.

He said: "However, ISPs cannot monitor or record the type of information passed over their network. ISPs are no more able to inspect and filter every single packet passing across their network than the Post Office is able to open every envelope."

"ISPs deal with many more packets of data each day than postal services and data protection legislation actually prevents ISPs from looking at the content of the packets sent," he added.

The British Phonographic Industry was pleased at the government's tough line.

"We greatly welcome the government reiterating its view that ISPs should work with us to tackle the problem of internet piracy, or else face legislation," said Geoff Taylor, chief executive of the BPI.

"ISPs operate the pathways to digital music consumers. Through our talks with the ISP community we are hopeful that together we can arrive at voluntary co-operative agreements that work to the benefit of the whole digital marketplace," he added.

The iPM programme also spoke to renowned blogger Cory Doctorow who described the idea as "misbegotten".

"It represents the opinion of someone who doesn't understand technology very well, and hasn't really thought through the implications of what he's promising.

You'd be hard pressed to find anyone who's an actual computer scientist involved in digital signal processing who believes that you can accurately identify copyrighted works with any kind of reliability in a variety of situations," he said.

He believed the idea would createa "giant toxic pool of personally idenitifying private information" that ISPs would not be able to keep secret.

"You will dismantle the fundamentals of the democratic state, which is to be free in your person, your mind and your conversation from scrutiny and surveillance. So this is a really misbegotten idea," he told iPM.

Time to choose Frostbite agony Stolen Generations

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

'One Laptop' a hit in Peruvian village

Sunday, January 13, 2008

art.onelaptop.kids.eat.ap.jpg

ARAHUAY, Peru (AP) -- Doubts about whether poor, rural children really can benefit from quirky little computers evaporate as quickly as the morning dew in this hilltop Andean village, where 50 primary school children got machines from the One Laptop Per Child project six months ago.

A group of children have breakfast at a public dining room reading information on their laptop in Peru.

These offspring of peasant families whose monthly earnings rarely exceed the cost of one of the $188 laptops -- people who can ill afford pencil and paper much less books -- can't get enough of their "XO" laptops.

At breakfast, they're already powering up the combination library/videocam/audio recorder/music maker/drawing kits.

At night, they're dozing off in front of them -- if they've managed to keep older siblings from waylaying the coveted machines.

"It's really the kind of conditions that we designed for," Walter Bender, president of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology spinoff, said of this agrarian backwater up a precarious dirt road.

Founded in 2005 by former MIT Media Lab director Nicholas Negroponte, the One Laptop program has retreated from early boasts that developing-world governments would snap up millions of the pint-sized laptops at $100 each.

In a backhanded tribute, One Laptop now faces homegrown competitors everywhere from Brazil to India -- and a full-court press from Intel Corp.'s more power-hungry Classmate.

But no competitor approaches the XO in innovation. It is hard drive-free, runs on the Linux operating system and stretches wireless networks with "mesh" technology that lets each computer in a village relay data to the others.

Mass production began last month and Negroponte, brother of U.S. Deputy Secretary of State John Negroponte, says he expects at least 1.5 million machines to be sold by next November. Even that would be far less than Negroponte originally envisioned. The higher-than-initially-advertised price and a lack of the Windows operating system, still being tested for the XO, have dissuaded many potential government buyers.

Peru made the single biggest order to date -- more than 272,000 machines -- in its quest to turn around a primary education system that the World Economic Forum recently ranked last among 131 countries surveyed. Uruguay was the No. 2 buyers of the laptops, inking a contract for 100,000.

Negroponte said 150,000 more laptops will get shipped to countries including Rwanda, Mongolia, Haiti, and Afghanistan in early 2008 through "Give One, Get One," a U.S.-based promotion ending December 31 in which you buy a pair of laptops for $399 and donate one or both.

The children of Arahuay prove One Laptop's transformative conceit: that you can revolutionize education and democratize the Internet by giving a simple, durable, power-stingy but feature-packed laptop to the worlds' poorest kids.

"Some tell me that they don't want to be like their parents, working in the fields," first-grade teacher Erica Velasco says of her pupils. She had just sent them to the Internet to seek out photos of invertebrates -- animals without backbones.

Antony, 12, wants to become an accountant.

Alex, 7, aspires to be a lawyer.

Kevin, 9, wants to play trumpet.

Saida, 10, is already a promising videographer, judging from her artful recording of the town's recent Fiesta de la Virgen.

"What they work with most is the (built-in) camera. They love to record," says Maria Antonieta Mendoza, an Education Ministry psychologist studying the Arahuay pilot to devise strategies for the big rollout when the new school year begins in March.

Before the laptops, the only cameras the kids at Santiago Apostol school saw in this population-800 hamlet arrived with tourists who visit for festivals or to see local Inca ruins.

Arahuay's lone industry is agriculture. Surrounding fields yield avocados, mangoes, potatoes, corn, alfalfa and cherimoya.

Many adults share only weekends with their children, spending the work week in fields many hours' walk from town and relying on charities to help keep their families nourished.

When they finish school, young people tend to abandon the village.

Peru's head of educational technology, Oscar Becerra, is betting the One Laptop program can reverse this rural exodus to the squalor of Lima's shantytowns four hours away.

It's the best answer yet to "a global crisis of education" in which curricula have no relevance, he said. "If we make education pertinent, something the student enjoys, then it won't matter if the classroom's walls are straw or the students are sitting on fruit boxes."

Indeed, Arahuay's elementary school population rose by 10 when families learned the laptop pilot was coming, said Guillermo Lazo, the school's director.

The XOs that Peru is buying will be distributed to pupils in 9,000 elementary schools from the Pacific to the Amazon basin where a single teacher serves all grades, Becerra said.

Although Peru boasts thousands of rural satellite downlinks that provide Internet access, only about 4,000 of the schools getting XOs will be connected, said Becerra.

Negroponte says One Laptop is committed to helping Peru overcome that hurdle. Without Internet access, he believes, the program is incomplete.

Teachers will get 2 days of training on the laptops, Becerra said. Each machine will initially be loaded with about 100 copyright-free books. Where applicable, texts in native languages will be included, he added. The machines will also have a chat function that will let kids make faraway friends over the Internet.

Critics of the rollout have two key concerns.

The first is the ability of teachers -- poorly trained and equipped to begin with -- to cope with profoundly disruptive technology.

Eduardo Villanueva, a communications professor at Lima's Catholic University, fears "a general disruption of the educational system that will manifest itself in the students overwhelming the teachers."

To counter that fear, Becerra said the government is offering $150 grants to qualifying teachers toward the purchase of conventional laptops, for which it is also arranging low-interest loans.

The second big concern is maintenance.

For every 100 units it will distribute to students, Peru is buying one extra for parts. But there is no tech support program. Students and teachers will have to do it.

"What you want is for the kids to do the repairs," said Negroponte, who believes such tinkering is itself a valuable lesson. "I think the kids can repair 95 percent of the laptops."

Tech support is nevertheless a serious issue in many countries, Negroponte acknowledged in a phone interview.

One Laptop is currently bidding on a contract with Brazil's government that Negroponte says demanded unrealistically onerous support requirements.

The XO machines are water resistant, rugged and designed to last five years. They have no fan so they won't suck up dust, are built to withstand drops from a meter and a half and can absorb power spikes typical of places with irregular electricity.

Mendoza, the psychologist, is overjoyed that the program stipulates that kids get ownership of the laptops.

Take Kevin, the aspiring trumpet player.

Sitting in his dirt-floor kitchen as his mother cooks lunch, he draws a soccer field on his XO, then erases it. Kevin plays a song by "Caliente," his favorite combo, that he recorded off Arahuay's single TV channel. He shows a reporter photos he took of him with his 3-year-old brother.

A bare light bulb hangs by a wire from the ceiling. A hen bobs around the floor. There are no books in this two-room house. Kevin's parents didn't get past the sixth grade.

Indeed, the laptop project also has adults in its sights.

Parents in Arahuay are asking Mendoza, the visiting psychologist, what the Internet can do for them.

Among them is Charito Arrendondo, 39, who sheds brief tears of joy when a reporter asks what the laptop belonging to ruddy-cheeked Miluska -- the youngest of her six children -- has meant to her. Miluska's father, it turns out, abandoned the family when she was 1.

"We never imagined having a computer," said Arrendondo, a cook.

Is she afraid to use the laptop, as is typical of many Arahuay parents, about half of whom are illiterate?

"No, I like it. Sometimes when I'm alone and the kids are not around I turn it on and poke around."

Arrendondo likes to play checkers on the laptop.

"It's also got chess, which I sort of know," she said, pausing briefly.

"I'm going to learn."

Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


Source from: edition.cnn.com

Games violence study is launched

Wednesday, December 26, 2007

Video games for sale
All games in the UK are regulated
The government is asking for evidence for a new study of the effect of violent computer games on children.

Psychologist Tanya Byron will head the study, which will also examine how to protect children from online material.

The review is due to be launched by Dr Byron - together with Schools Secretary Ed Balls and Culture Secretary James Purnell - at a school in east London.

The games industry's association Elspa said it would co-operate - but it was too often blamed for society's ills.

Paul Jackson, of Elspa (the Entertainment and Leisure Software Publishers' Association), said the body had already met with Dr Byron and would work with the government on the review.

We are very responsible and keen to ensure that our products are only played by those who they are designed for

But he said the industry was "too often blamed for everything from obesity to youth violence".

He said: "It is just not true and it's not appropriate."

He added: "We feel quite positively about this review. It's clear the review is about making sure parents are properly informed about what their youngsters are playing and what they are accessing on the internet."

Dr Byron told BBC News 24: "The study will be about what industry is doing already to protect children and what more could be done to ensure they have a positive experience on the internet and with games."

Speaking at the launch of the review at a school in Barking, Essex, she said: "Video gaming and the internet themselves are a very positive and important part of children's and young children's growing up and learning and development. But it is also about saying where are the risks?"

The review is expected to last six months.

'Singled out'

Veteran developer David Braben, of Frontier games, asked why games were being singled out.

"A review might be useful but it should not just look at one media, especially when media are intersecting," he said.

He added: "Historically there has always been in government a Luddite sentiment - whatever the new industry is tends to take the blame of the latest ailment of society.

"We do tend to be the people who get the blame first at the moment. And that is a tragedy - because this industry is one of the most interesting media."

Philip Oliver, chief executive of Blitz games, said more education was needed for parents.

"They aren't paying attention to the certificates. That is partly because they don't understand them and have a distorted image of games - that either they are harmless or totally evil."

The review is launched a day after the British Board of Film Classification refused a certificate for Manhunt 2 for a second time.

Mr Oliver said the decision was proof "the system is working".

According to Elspa, only 2% of games released in the UK receive an 18 certificate and the average age of a gamer is 28.

'Higher standards'

Mr Jackson said: "We are a very important British industry. We are very responsible and keen to ensure that our products are only played by those who they are designed for."

Margaret Robertson, a video games consultant and former editor of Edge magazine, said the industry felt it was doing as much as it could.

"The games industry is holding itself to higher standards than the film industry. This is a solved problem.

"Allowing that, everyone is united in not wanting material for older gamers to get into the hands of children."

She added: "This report may start finding some wider ways to do that."Epic battle Delays, delays Beer and Buddhism

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Games violence study is launched

Tuesday, December 4, 2007

Video games for sale
All games in the UK are regulated
The government is asking for evidence for a new study of the effect of violent computer games on children.

Psychologist Tanya Byron will head the study, which will also examine how to protect children from online material.

The review is due to be launched by Dr Byron - together with Schools Secretary Ed Balls and Culture Secretary James Purnell - at a school in east London.

The games industry's association Elspa said it would co-operate - but it was too often blamed for society's ills.

Paul Jackson, of Elspa (the Entertainment and Leisure Software Publishers' Association), said the body had already met with Dr Byron and would work with the government on the review.

We are very responsible and keen to ensure that our products are only played by those who they are designed for

But he said the industry was "too often blamed for everything from obesity to youth violence".

He said: "It is just not true and it's not appropriate."

He added: "We feel quite positively about this review. It's clear the review is about making sure parents are properly informed about what their youngsters are playing and what they are accessing on the internet."

Dr Byron told BBC News 24: "The study will be about what industry is doing already to protect children and what more could be done to ensure they have a positive experience on the internet and with games."

Speaking at the launch of the review at a school in Barking, Essex, she said: "Video gaming and the internet themselves are a very positive and important part of children's and young children's growing up and learning and development. But it is also about saying where are the risks?"

The review is expected to last six months.

'Singled out'

Veteran developer David Braben, of Frontier games, asked why games were being singled out.

"A review might be useful but it should not just look at one media, especially when media are intersecting," he said.

He added: "Historically there has always been in government a Luddite sentiment - whatever the new industry is tends to take the blame of the latest ailment of society.

"We do tend to be the people who get the blame first at the moment. And that is a tragedy - because this industry is one of the most interesting media."

Philip Oliver, chief executive of Blitz games, said more education was needed for parents.

"They aren't paying attention to the certificates. That is partly because they don't understand them and have a distorted image of games - that either they are harmless or totally evil."

The review is launched a day after the British Board of Film Classification refused a certificate for Manhunt 2 for a second time.

Mr Oliver said the decision was proof "the system is working".

According to Elspa, only 2% of games released in the UK receive an 18 certificate and the average age of a gamer is 28.

'Higher standards'

Mr Jackson said: "We are a very important British industry. We are very responsible and keen to ensure that our products are only played by those who they are designed for."

Margaret Robertson, a video games consultant and former editor of Edge magazine, said the industry felt it was doing as much as it could.

"The games industry is holding itself to higher standards than the film industry. This is a solved problem.

"Allowing that, everyone is united in not wanting material for older gamers to get into the hands of children."

She added: "This report may start finding some wider ways to do that."Back to battle Ice scream Roma ruin

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Industry reacts to games review

Leading figures in the games industry give their views on the review.

DAVID BRABEN, FOUNDER FRONTIER GAMES

Unifying the two would be helpful. Creating a review that is just one narrow part of the entertainment industry is a mistake.

Perhaps 18 certificate games should not be sold in retail that is available to children

Historically there has always been in government a Luddite sentiment - whatever the new industry trends to take the blame of the latest ailment of society. This is an industry which often does not answer back.

Occasionally game ratings are seen as aspirational - I've seen games with 18 ratings that do not deserve it. If you look at comparison with film, the industry is dealing with similar issues.

We don't have real enforcement of ratings. Perhaps 18 certificate games should not be sold in retail that is available to children. Just like Adult Only games in the US.

It's a disgrace that there are games designed for 18 year olds being played by eight year olds. There is an expectation of "it's only a game".

It's as much an education issue as anything else and it applies equally to films.

"We do tend to be the people who get the blame first at the moment. And that is a tragedy - because this industry is one of the most interesting media.

PHILIP OLIVER, CHIEF EXECUTIVE BLITZ GAMES

Is the industry doing the right thing? I firmly believe we are.

Everything is clearly labelled. All the games have certificates on them.

I feel the breakdown in the games industry, as it is in every other media, is with parent's understanding.

They aren't paying attention to the certificates. That is partly because they don't understand them and have a distorted image of games - that either they are harmless or totally evil.

The games industry makes titles for older gamers because that is where the market is. They are not aimed at children

We need to educate parents - and if that is what this government review does, then I am very happy about that.

Only a small percentage of games are rated 15 or over and the average age of a gamer is 28 years old.

The games industry makes titles for older gamers because that is where the market is. They are not aimed at children.

If the movie industry didn't make titles for 18 audiences, you wouldn't have Schindler's List, Saving Private Ryan and Reservoir Dogs.

There are games that don't need to be made, such as Manhunt 2. That title was banned, which shows the system is working.

MARGARET ROBERTSON, FORMER EDITOR OF EDGE MAGAZINE

There is need for a review but probably not for more legislation. From within the games industry this problem is well mapped.

The games industry is holding itself to higher standards than the film industry. This is a solved problem

The UK games industry feels, quite justifiably, they are doing as much as they reasonably can so shop that games are for all and not just for children and therefore some of them have adult themes and are not suitable for younger players.

The combination of the BBFC and the Pegi European ratings and the size of these ratings on boxes - typically larger than certificates on DVDs - is an indication of that seriousness.

Staff at most game shops are trained but again and again what we hear is that there is still a problem of getting parents to understand that a game may not be suitable for their children.

It's hard to see what more could be done. The games industry is holding itself to higher standards than the film industry. This is a solved problem.

Allowing that, everyone is united in not wanting material for older gamers to get into the hands of children.

This report may start finding some wider ways to do that.

PAUL JACKSON, CHAIRMAN OF ELSPA

The video games industry is a very responsible industry and we are very tightly regulated. We are keen to work with government in any way we can.

I think the video games industry is this year's whipping boy

We are a successful industry. The average age of gamers today is about 28 so we reserve the right to make content for all our consumers.

The key for us is to make sure parents understand age ratings. There is no difference between an 18-rated film and an 18-rated game.

I think the video games industry is this year's whipping boy. too often we are blamed for everything from obesity to youth violence it is just not true and it's not appropriate.

We are a very important British industry and we are very responsible keen to ensure that our products are only played by those who they are designed for.Back to battle Ice scream Roma ruin

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Africa's digital poster child

Thursday, November 29, 2007

There is a race to connect the next billion people worldwide and one of the main arenas where it is being played out is Nigeria, the most populous country in Africa.

In the West African nation, home to more than 140m people, humanitarian efforts rub shoulders with commercial schemes to bridge the digital divide.

The Ministry of Education is currently evaluating schemes from Microsoft, Intel and the One Laptop per Child group to give the country's 30 million school-aged children access to computers.

Although no decision has been made about which, if any, it will buy into on a large scale, some schemes are already starting to move ahead.

"There is a commitment to roll out our project in 200 schools," said David Ibhawoh of Intel.

The chip manufacturer is promoting its Classmate PC (CMPC) in Nigeria to various organisations as well as government and has set up a pilot project at Jabi Secondary School on the outskirts of Abuja to show off the technology.

The project is the first in Africa and is part of Intel's World Ahead programme aimed at bringing technology to people around the world.

"When we started this program there was no infrastructure. The classroom did not have any desks and chairs," said Mr Ibhawoh, who helped set up the Jabi School trial.

Today, the situation couldn't be more different.

The school is in the process of an extensive building programme. The original school buildings are all now topped with gleaming aluminium roofs and the orderly classrooms pack the latest technology.

"The pilot project consists of 280 computers, 8 teacher laptops, digital content, Wimax for internet access, and a repository where we can view content offline," said Dennis Etsuke, technical manager at the school.

In addition, each computer lab is equipped with an expensive interactive whiteboard.

The renovation has been paid for by the government and Intel, with the chip firm covering the majority of the costs of the technology.

High achievers

At the cornerstone of the project is the CMPC.

"There are three basic differences with a standard laptop," said Dennis Etsuke, technical manager at the school. "It is smaller; it doesn't have a CD-Rom drive and it doesn't have a hard drive."

Children's reactions

"All of the PCs connect to the teacher's laptop," he explained. "The teacher can then broadcast her lecture and the pupils can respond to that."

Lessons at the school are very orderly and structured. The teacher introduces a topic on the white board and pupils take notes and do exercise on their individual Windows-based PCs.

"The curriculum has not changed but it has changed the way the children learn - it has really got them interested," said Mrs Adeola Adiome, one of the teachers at the school.

"The laptops were introduced to just one class initially and when we compared them with another class that did not have [the laptops] we saw a great gap in their performances.

The headmistress of the school, Mrs Esther Odekina agrees.

"My students have improved greatly - each one scores now above 60%," she said. "My teachers have also benefited - most of them now are computer literate, including me"

Washing machines

At the moment only the oldest pupils have access to the laptops, but the school hopes to start moving them between different classrooms to give access to all 750 students.

Classmate's features

In addition, the local community is benefiting from the school's internet access.

"Parents come here also to browse the internet for free in the evening," said Mrs Odekina. "Education is for all so we allow them to use it."

Entrepreneurs are also setting up around the school, piggy-backing on the wireless signal that floods the area, according to Mr Ibhawoh.

"There is a new business model where people browse the internet whilst having their car washed," he said.

Initially, he said, there were problems with spammers using the network, so now the school takes the details of regular users and provides them with a username and password for a small fee.

The money provides an additional revenue stream for the school.

Connection cost

Although Jabi is clearly a success some people questions whether the programme can be scaled up across the country.

At the moment Jabi School acts as the poster child for the Intel scheme in Nigeria and has clearly had a lot of money spent on it by both government and Intel.

Wimax aerial
Wimax covers the whole of the Abuja metropolitan area

Its pristine buildings, well resourced classrooms and tidy pupils stand in stark contrast to other schools we saw.

Nigeria has more than 20 million primary school children and more than 6 million in secondary school.

At the moment, each CMPC currently costs between $300 and $400

Intel will donate a further 3,000 CMPCs and has said the price will come down for large orders. In addition it has said it will train 150,000 teachers in the country over the next five years.

However, a large scale roll-out of the scheme to every child still represents a potentially huge investment for a country where, according to the World Bank, the Gross National Income per person is $640.

In particular, all net-based projects in Nigeria face high connectivity costs.

The 256 kilobits per second (kbps) Wimax connection at Jabi School, paid for by the government, currently costs $900 a month on top of $1500 for equipment.

Although costs are projected to come down for Wimax and other systems, they still remain a huge barrier to any scheme hoping to digitally unite Nigeria.

Digital bridge

Some have also questioned Intel's motivation for pushing the CMPC in Nigeria and claim that the programme is no more than an attempt by the firm to saturate a market before its competitors.

Earlier this year, Nicholas Negroponte, the man behind the not-for profit One Laptop per Child (OLPC) group, accused Intel of selling the CMPC below cost to drive him out of markets.

Professor Negroponte said he believed that Intel was doing it because the OLPC machine used a processor designed by the chip-maker's main competitor, AMD.

But since the feud, the two groups have united, although there is still little evidence of it in on the ground in Nigeria.

Mr Ibhawoh does not deny that there is a commercial element to the programme and that the firm will make money from the scheme but, he said, it was primarily about social responsibility.

"Who decides to train 150,000 teachers in one country, who decides to design a digital curriculum for kids around a country, who pays for that?," he said.

"Our goal is to connect the next one billion."

"For us it's not about who gets the market share - it's about how many people we are able to empower, how many people are able to bridge the digital divide."

Fantastical feast Honeymoon over 'St Petersburg clan'

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Glimpsing Nigeria's digital lifeline

$100 Laptop in Nigeria's Galadima Primary School Until recently there was nothing that marked out Galadima primary school as anything out of the ordinary.

The government-run school, flanked by a red dust road on the outskirts of Abuja, Nigeria, taught about 300 pupils who congregated from the surrounding rural area.

But in March this year, the scruffy primary became part of a remarkable experiment. It was the first in Africa to get its hands on the so-called $100 laptop, a rugged device aimed at helping children in the developing world get the most from their education.

The tough machines, conceived by the US-based One Laptop per Child (OLPC) group, were designed to replace dog-eared text books and traditional teaching.

The school was given around 300 of the low-cost laptops along with a satellite internet link known as VSAT, a power generator and solar panels. The idea was to see if the machines would survive the ultimate test: children.

"We wanted to bring the laptops to an environment where the kids would drop it, put it in water and do everything you wouldn't want to do to a normal laptop," explained Ayo Kusamotu, a lawyer and volunteer with OLPC Nigeria, an independent group set-up to support OLPC in Nigeria.

The hardware trial ran for five months.

"We've actually learned a lot from that trial - really simple things that are almost mundane but important," explained Walter Bender of OLPC.

"For example, some of the desks in Galadima are at an angle and we learned that you've got to put rubber feet on the laptop otherwise it will slide off. So now production laptops have rubber feet."

Although, the trial has now ended OLPC Nigeria has continued to fund and support the school's use of the computers. It remains one of just a handful of places in the world where the OLPC vision can be seen "in the wild" and visiting it is an uplifting experience.

Village pride

The children - most of whom had never seen a computer before March - have clearly embraced the green and white machines.

It is one of the happiest things that has happened to the school

Even before entering the school grounds, visitors are accosted by hordes of animated children waving their laptops, eager to show what they can do with them.

Children stream from doorways and alleys wanting to take a "snap" with the laptop's onboard camera whilst others shoot video files and then excitedly show each other the results.

The more studious show off the graphs and pictures they have drawn and the notes they have typed in class.

There is a clear sense of enjoyment and pride in both ownership and use of the machines.

One girl was even wearing the power cord as a necklace.

And that pride continues through to the packed classrooms - where up to 90 or 100 pupils are squeezed into one room - and is evident in both children and teacher.

"It is one of the happiest things that has happened to the school," Miss Manzo, one of the teachers at the school confided.

'Yo-yo' power chord

Not only has it raised the status of the school, she said, but it has also improved learning at school and the surrounding community.

She added: "But it is not only in the school they make use of the laptop. They use it at home and even help to teach their parents."

Miss Manzo said that both the children and the teachers had easily learnt how to use the XO laptops, as they are known.

At the moment the laptops are used to augment the text books and black boards rather than replace them.

"One of the biggest uses of the laptop is for note-taking in class," said Mr Kusamotu.

In addition, he said, teachers use the preloaded encyclopaedia to teach classes.

During our visit we saw a lesson on the mammalian eye based on the preloaded content along with maths lessons that used the calculator.

Although there are no numbers that show what effect, if any, the laptops have had, the teachers remain convinced of their worth.

"I pray that the government will try and help every child in Nigeria get access to this," said the headmistress of Galadima, Mrs Juliana Okowkno.

Digital distraction

However, aspects of digital life at Galadima are not perfect. What are small problems at one school could become serious issues if, and when, millions of the laptops are rolled out across the country.

Girl walking with XO laptop
The children are allowed to take the laptops home with them

For example, more than 40 of the prototype machines have either been lost, stolen or broken since March. This has knock-on consequences, meaning that that not every child has a laptop on which to follow lessons.

In addition, the laptops can be a distraction - often pupils play games on their computer rather than follow the class.

It is also apparent from visiting Galadima the level of support a large-scale roll out of the programme would require.

Teachers would need to be trained, technicians would need to be on hand to troubleshoot problems and the laptops and its peripherals would also need maintenance.

Some of the children have learnt how to fix broken keyboards and remove the screens and batteries. They act as engineers for the whole of the school - fixing friends laptops as and when needs arise. But software and infrastructure problems may be more tricky.

For example, the solar chargers strapped to the roof of Galadima school had been not set up correctly - we were told they were "misaligned" - and are useless.

Net worth

However, perhaps the greatest difficulty that will face schools that follow Galadima is the internet.

Earlier this year, some of the pupils were found to be accessing pornography through the laptops.

Vsat dish
The internet connection is powered by a diesel generator

Although filters can be added relatively easily, there is a bigger problem and one that is typical of many developing economies: cost.

"VSAT is still very expensive," said Mr Olanrewaju Oke of internet service provider Accelon.

"For a 1.2m dish and a one watt radio it comes in at about $2,500."

In addition, a 128Kbps connection - around a quarter of the speed of a typical broadband connection - is around $350 per month, or $4,200 per year. That is on top of the cost of the laptops - currently $188 apiece.

During the trial, Accelon provided the connection for free but now the school is on its own and as a result, the link has been cut - although OLPC Nigeria had asked for the internet to be restored during our visit.

Mr Oke believes that cost will come down in the same way as it did in the mobile phone sector. He has put forward a long term plan in the event the Nigeria government buys into OLPC that would see schools sharing a connection.

"We're looking for a situation where we can provide good clean access to these schools for anything from $100 to $150 a month," he said.

"It's a starting point and eventually we would like to get close to where Europe is at 50, 60 or 70 dollars a month."

Without government intervention it is difficult to see how many schools in Nigeria - and elsewhere - could afford to get online.

But Mr Kusamotu does not believe it is a problem.

"It is not a stumbling block," he said. "Having the XO, even without the internet, is an extension of the classroom."

Fantastical feast Honeymoon over 'St Petersburg clan'

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Anti file-sharing laws considered

Friday, November 23, 2007

Lord Triesman
The government cannot tolerate stealing, said Lord Triesman
The UK government could legislate to crack down on illegal file-sharers, a senior politician has told the BBC's iPM programme.

Lord Triesman, the parliamentary Under Secretary for Innovation, Universities and Skills, said intellectual property theft would not be tolerated.

"If we can't get voluntary arrangements we will legislate," he said.

The comments could prove controversial with privacy advocates and internet service providers.

Lord Triesman called on internet service providers to take a "more activist role" in the problem of illegal file-sharing.

Data banks

There are ongoing talks between internet service providers and the music industry and these are, said Lord Triesman, "progressing more promisingly than people might have thought six months ago".

"For the most part I think there are going to be successful voluntary schemes between the creative industries and ISPs. Our preferred position is that we shouldn't have to regulate," he said.

He admitted that the technology necessary to track illegal file sharing would mean that "it is quite possible to know where it is happening and who it is happening with".

While he said that the government had no interest in "hounding 14-year-olds who shared music", it was intent on tracking down those who made multiple copies for profit.

"Where people have registered music as an intellectual property I believe we will be able to match data banks of that music to music going out and being exchanged on the net," he said.

"We have some simple choices to make. If creative artists can't earn a living as a result of the work they produce, then we will kill off creative artists and that would be a tragedy."

Mere conduit

Man being arrested
This week a man was arrested in connection with pirate music site

The debate centre around peer-to-peer (P2P) technology, applications that allow internet users to exchange files with each other directly or through a mediating server.

Computer users with the same type of P2P application can connect to each other and directly access files from one another's hard drives.

Some people are using peer-to-peer applications to copy or distribute files including copyrighted material such as music, films and software without paying royalties.

People who do this may be infringing the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

There have been various crack-downs on such applications. Most recently the UK-run members-only site OiNK was shut down and several properties in the UK and Holland were raided.

'Misbegotten idea'

The Internet Service Providers Association has always maintained that it cannot be held responsible for illegal peer-to-peer traffic because it is "merely a conduit" of such material.

"ISPA does not support abuses of copyright and intellectual property theft," said an ISPA spokesman.

He said: "However, ISPs cannot monitor or record the type of information passed over their network. ISPs are no more able to inspect and filter every single packet passing across their network than the Post Office is able to open every envelope."

"ISPs deal with many more packets of data each day than postal services and data protection legislation actually prevents ISPs from looking at the content of the packets sent," he added.

The British Phonographic Industry was pleased at the government's tough line.

"We greatly welcome the government reiterating its view that ISPs should work with us to tackle the problem of internet piracy, or else face legislation," said Geoff Taylor, chief executive of the BPI.

"ISPs operate the pathways to digital music consumers. Through our talks with the ISP community we are hopeful that together we can arrive at voluntary co-operative agreements that work to the benefit of the whole digital marketplace," he added.

The iPM programme also spoke to renowned blogger Cory Doctorow who described the idea as "misbegotten".

"It represents the opinion of someone who doesn't understand technology very well, and hasn't really thought through the implications of what he's promising.

You'd be hard pressed to find anyone who's an actual computer scientist involved in digital signal processing who believes that you can accurately identify copyrighted works with any kind of reliability in a variety of situations," he said.

He believed the idea would createa "giant toxic pool of personally idenitifying private information" that ISPs would not be able to keep secret.

"You will dismantle the fundamentals of the democratic state, which is to be free in your person, your mind and your conversation from scrutiny and surveillance. So this is a really misbegotten idea," he told iPM.

Shock to system Day in pictures Luxury living

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Warning on e-government 'risks'

State opening of Parliament, BBC
Trust in government emerges many different ways says the report
Governments need to do more to ensure they preserve trust as they put more services online, says a report.

Emerging from a European Commission project, it warns that technology could lessen the trust governments have instilled in citizens before now.

Officials must move beyond security measures to reassure people about how they are being treated, it said.

The report comes as the UK government tries to reassure Britons after losing data records for 25 million people.

Trust network

The report was written by a research body, bankrolled by the EC's Information and Society Unit, that is looking at "citizen-centric" e-government.

The cc:eGov unit points out that increasingly technology, often in the form of websites, is the means by which citizens encounter local and central government.

Frank Harris, author of the report, wrote: "People learn to trust others through experience, and through judgement based on both direct and referred experience."

The danger, he warned, was that these interfaces did not engender the same feelings of trust that have emerged via more traditional routes.

He added that to engender trust in electronic channels required much more than the basic requirements of security.

Citizens may not recognise the significance of technical measures, such as encryption, which try to stop criminals eavesdropping while they use a government website.

Instead, he said, more obvious means, such as kite marks or privacy seals, may be needed to reassure people.

He called for the establishment of a clear "pact" between citizens and government that says clearly what will be done with information people hand over, and what happens when data is lost or things go wrong.

As evidence of what form this might take, the report cites the Dutch "e-citizen charter", a 10-point code of conduct the government has pledged to abide by.

Without a mechanism for engendering trust, efforts to drive e-government may struggle, wrote Mr Harris.Luxury living Day in pictures It's quiz time!

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Government mulls broadband help

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Stephen Timms, Minister for Competitiveness
Mr Timms sees broadband infrastructure as a "personal priority"
The UK government is considering intervening in the way broadband is rolled out, in an effort to speed up the deployment of super-fast services.

Stephen Timms, Minister for Competitiveness, ordered a summit to look at the role of government in providing next-generation broadband.

While other countries are investing in new ways to deliver higher bandwidth, the UK is seen as lagging behind.

Mr Timms said broadband infrastructure was one of his "personal priorities".

"Today we face a new challenge. Other countries are starting to invest in new, fibre-based infrastructure, delivering considerably higher bandwidth than is available in the UK today," Mr Timms told the Broadband Stakeholder Group and others attending a meeting on Tuesday evening.

"I have decided to chair a high level summit later this year to consider the circumstances that might trigger public sector intervention and the form that intervention might take," he said.

Huge costs

The event was organised by the Broadband Stakeholder Group to outline its own plans to improve the way next-generation broadband is rolled out in the UK.

According to Richard Allan, a member of the Broadband Stakeholder Group and director of government affairs at Cisco, the UK needs to act now in order to keep its place in the top 25% of broadband nations.

"That should be one of the targets that the government sets if it wants to stay economically competitive," he said.

Mr Allan believes that the UK should have 40% of its citizens connected to fibre that can deliver broadband speeds of up to 100Mbps (megabits per second) by 2012.

"The current copper-based system is limited by ADSL which means 24 megabits under very good conditions," he said.

It is estimated that upgrading the whole of the UK to a fibre-based network could cost 10-15bn.

While other countries, including France, Germany and Italy are already looking at ways of improving the so-called access or last-mile network which connects to people's homes, there is so far little investment in the UK.

Sewer
UK sewers may not be suitable for fibre

According to Mr Allan, the reasons for this are part-historical.

"There is evidence that the cost of civil engineering work in the UK is particularly high," he said.

He believes government intervention in lowering these costs as well as help with planning laws and providing the necessary ducting for fibre would be a step in the right direction.

In some countries ducts for fibre have been made available via municipal sewers although Mr Allan is not sure this is the solution in the UK.

"Traditionally UK sewers are deeper and they are not municipally owned but there are other ways to keep the disruption of digging up roads to a minimum, for example with micro ducts which sees fibre blown through long runs," he said.

The BSG is also calling on Ofcom to provide a regulatory framework to support investment in next-generation networks.In pictures Importing workers Dollar's dazzle

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Symington: I saw a UFO in the Arizona sky

Monday, November 12, 2007

art.symington.jpg

Former Arizona Governor Fife Symington will be moderating a November 12 event at the National Press Club where he will discuss the Phoenix Lights incident. He says he will be joined by 14 former high-ranking military and government officials from seven countries who will share evidence from what they call their own UFO experiences and investigations.

Fife Symington says he nearly had a close encounter while governor of Arizona.

(CNN) -- In 1997, during my second term as governor of Arizona, I saw something that defied logic and challenged my reality.

I witnessed a massive delta-shaped, craft silently navigate over Squaw Peak, a mountain range in Phoenix, Arizona. It was truly breathtaking. I was absolutely stunned because I was turning to the west looking for the distant Phoenix Lights.

To my astonishment this apparition appeared; this dramatically large, very distinctive leading edge with some enormous lights was traveling through the Arizona sky.

As a pilot and a former Air Force Officer, I can definitively say that this craft did not resemble any man-made object I'd ever seen. And it was certainly not high-altitude flares because flares don't fly in formation.

The incident was witnessed by hundreds -- if not thousands -- of people in Arizona, and my office was besieged with phone calls from very concerned Arizonians.

The growing hysteria intensified when the story broke nationally. I decided to lighten the mood of the state by calling a press conference where my chief of staff arrived in an alien costume. We managed to lessen the sense of panic but, at the same time, upset many of my constituents.

I would now like to set the record straight. I never meant to ridicule anyone. My office did make inquiries as to the origin of the craft, but to this day they remain unanswered.

Eventually the Air Force claimed responsibility stating that they dropped flares.

This is indicative of the attitude from official channels. We get explanations that fly in the face of the facts. Explanations like weather balloons, swamp gas and military flares.

I was never happy with the Air Force's silly explanation. There might very well have been military flares in the sky that evening, but what I and hundreds of others saw had nothing to do with that.

I now know that I am not alone. There are many high-ranking military, aviation and government officials who share my concerns. While on active duty, they have either witnessed a UFO incident or have conducted an official investigation into UFO cases relevant to aviation safety and national security.

By speaking out with me, these people are putting their reputations on the line. They have fought in wars, guarded top secret weapons arsenals and protected our nation's skies.

We want the government to stop putting out stories that perpetuate the myth that all UFOs can be explained away in down-to-earth conventional terms. Investigations need to be re-opened, documents need to be unsealed and the idea of an open dialogue can no longer be shunned.

Incidents like these are not going away. About a year ago, Chicago's O'Hare International Airport experienced a UFO event that made national and international headlines.

What I saw in the Arizona sky goes beyond conventional explanations. When it comes to events of this nature that are still completely unsolved, we deserve more openness in government, especially our own.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the writer.


Source from: edition.cnn.com

Net giants 'still failing China'

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

Google
Google has faced tough criticism of its China policy
Earlier this year net giants Google and Yahoo came under fire from Human Rights Watch and Reporters Sans Frontieres, for their activities in China. But is the criticism warranted?

In 2003 the Chinese police who had been monitoring message boards, blogs and personal emails, asked for the sign up account details of two anonymous bloggers.

These were handed over by Yahoo China to the Chinese Government.

More than 57 Chinese people have been arrested as result of discussing democracy on the internet, say Amnesty International.

Human Rights Watch, a New York based campaign group, says a line has been crossed.

"Google, Yahoo and Microsoft no longer carry out the censorship for the Chinese government," says Asia Director, Brad Adams, "they are the censor."

This comment stems from the lack of clarity over what is being censored, who has initiated it, and why.

There are two types of censoring at work. Firstly, whole websites are eliminated from Yahoo and Google in China.

De-listed sites

As Judy Lin, a former Reuters reporter in Beijing, says: "I found it very difficult to do my job.

I couldn't access the New York Times, The Washington Times, BBC News or any websites about Tiananmen square

"I couldn't access the New York Times, The Washington Times, BBC News or any websites about Tiananmen square."

Additionally, typing in certain words, such as democracy, human rights, and the Chinese opposition group Falungong will produce error pages.

In an official statement, Yahoo said: "It is our understanding that every internet and media company doing business in China receives a list of prohibited words.

"It's important to distinguish that as of October 2005, Ali baba now operates the combined entity including the Yahoo China business.

"We no longer manage day to day operations in China, so we do not have a copy of this list of prohibited words."

'Government's bidding'

"There was talk of a list that the Chinese government drew up and handed to the internet companies. There is no list, and Yahoo in particular is doing the Chinese Government's bidding by predicting which words will be problematic, testing them against the firewall and then implementing them."

Google China
Certain results are omitted from Google searches in China

Human Rights Watch has repeatedly asked for copies of this list, and has never been given it.

These firewalls are maintained because the whole of China is served by only nine servers, through which all internet traffic is directed.

In addition, both Reporters Sans Frontiers and Human Rights Watch maintain that Chinese censorship is some of the most elaborate and comprehensive in the world.

Julian Pain from RSF challenges the legal basis for these lists , saying: "These are not actually legal: nowhere in the Chinese constitution does it say that certain words are illegal on internet sites."

Despite this China is viewed by the internet companies as a very lucrative market, with more than 100 million users online at any one time.

Yahoo, Google and other internet firms maintain they are interested in pursuing the utopian ideals on which they were founded.

Yahoo says the internet is a "positive force in China and a growing Chinese middle class is benefiting greatly from more education, communication, and technology".

'Giant market'

Brad Adams understands why there is such a furore over this issue because "in the future everything will be done on the internet: shopping, information retrieval and voting".

Chinese citizens are not interested in overthrowing the government

Chinese journalist Bu Hua, and Media Academic Shou Ming say there are more than 30,000 people involved in maintaining censorship within the Chinese government, monitoring information and discussions on message boards.

However both emphasise that the effects of this censorship are relatively small.

"Chinese citizens are not interested in overthrowing the government, or this Western concept of the public sphere" says Shou, "they want to talk about day to day concerns.

Yahoo China
Yahoo says it bans words on an official list from the Chinese government

"Whilst each case is very sad for the people involved, fifty seven people arrested in a country of 1.4 billion is not very much."

Firewalls

Both her and Shou Ming use tactics like breaking up words or underscoring them to find ways around the censors.

Others in China use proxy servers - computers in another country which act as the gateway to the net outside of China.

Critics of internet companies like Google and Yahoo argue that despite the assurances they are still treading too softly. There is talk of an ethical code to be launched soon.

"There is no chance that China will throw out Yahoo, Microsoft or Google" says Brad Adams.

"Dissidents use their sites, which makes them 'honeypots' that the Chinese government can monitor. And the Chinese need the new technology and software these companies bring in, if only to copy it.

"If Google, Yahoo and Microsoft stand together and are divided and ruled by the Chinese, they will be able to uphold an ethical code."French flavour Day in pictures Q&A

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk

Industry reacts to games review

Sunday, November 4, 2007

Leading figures in the games industry give their views on the review.

DAVID BRABEN, FOUNDER FRONTIER GAMES

Unifying the two would be helpful. Creating a review that is just one narrow part of the entertainment industry is a mistake.

Perhaps 18 certificate games should not be sold in retail that is available to children

Historically there has always been in government a Luddite sentiment - whatever the new industry trends to take the blame of the latest ailment of society. This is an industry which often does not answer back.

Occasionally game ratings are seen as aspirational - I've seen games with 18 ratings that do not deserve it. If you look at comparison with film, the industry is dealing with similar issues.

We don't have real enforcement of ratings. Perhaps 18 certificate games should not be sold in retail that is available to children. Just like Adult Only games in the US.

It's a disgrace that there are games designed for 18 year olds being played by eight year olds. There is an expectation of "it's only a game".

It's as much an education issue as anything else and it applies equally to films.

"We do tend to be the people who get the blame first at the moment. And that is a tragedy - because this industry is one of the most interesting media.

PHILIP OLIVER, CHIEF EXECUTIVE BLITZ GAMES

Is the industry doing the right thing? I firmly believe we are.

Everything is clearly labelled. All the games have certificates on them.

I feel the breakdown in the games industry, as it is in every other media, is with parent's understanding.

They aren't paying attention to the certificates. That is partly because they don't understand them and have a distorted image of games - that either they are harmless or totally evil.

The games industry makes titles for older gamers because that is where the market is. They are not aimed at children

We need to educate parents - and if that is what this government review does, then I am very happy about that.

Only a small percentage of games are rated 15 or over and the average age of a gamer is 28 years old.

The games industry makes titles for older gamers because that is where the market is. They are not aimed at children.

If the movie industry didn't make titles for 18 audiences, you wouldn't have Schindler's List, Saving Private Ryan and Reservoir Dogs.

There are games that don't need to be made, such as Manhunt 2. That title was banned, which shows the system is working.

MARGARET ROBERTSON, FORMER EDITOR OF EDGE MAGAZINE

There is need for a review but probably not for more legislation. From within the games industry this problem is well mapped.

The games industry is holding itself to higher standards than the film industry. This is a solved problem

The UK games industry feels, quite justifiably, they are doing as much as they reasonably can so shop that games are for all and not just for children and therefore some of them have adult themes and are not suitable for younger players.

The combination of the BBFC and the Pegi European ratings and the size of these ratings on boxes - typically larger than certificates on DVDs - is an indication of that seriousness.

Staff at most game shops are trained but again and again what we hear is that there is still a problem of getting parents to understand that a game may not be suitable for their children.

It's hard to see what more could be done. The games industry is holding itself to higher standards than the film industry. This is a solved problem.

Allowing that, everyone is united in not wanting material for older gamers to get into the hands of children.

This report may start finding some wider ways to do that.

PAUL JACKSON, CHAIRMAN OF ELSPA

The video games industry is a very responsible industry and we are very tightly regulated. We are keen to work with government in any way we can.

I think the video games industry is this year's whipping boy

We are a successful industry. The average age of gamers today is about 28 so we reserve the right to make content for all our consumers.

The key for us is to make sure parents understand age ratings. There is no difference between an 18-rated film and an 18-rated game.

I think the video games industry is this year's whipping boy. too often we are blamed for everything from obesity to youth violence it is just not true and it's not appropriate.

We are a very important British industry and we are very responsible keen to ensure that our products are only played by those who they are designed for.Australian election Diplomatic deficit Fleeing the flood

Source from: news.bbc.co.uk